top of page

Warning! Some Images on this Page May be Offensive to Some Viewers. Please Use Discretion.

Death, Detritus, and Feces

Roadkill: What are Barriers to Dispersal?

For some, perhaps many of us, the idea of roadkill engenders a certain type of humor. There are multiple cookbooks on the subject,[1] for example, although most people would decline such fare based on the time it spent in the sun alone. Discussions of cooking and eating roadkill often involve flat shovels kept ready in the car trunk at all times. And, while the subject is often treated humorously, there are examples, such as that of Laurie Speakman, “The Moose Lady” of Alaska who works legally with the Alaska Moose Federation to “harvest” moose roadkill for distribution to a waiting list of groups including those that feed the hungry. About twenty states allow some collecting of accidental roadkill for food.[2] Roger M. Knutson’s book, Flattened Fauna: A Field Guide to Common Animals of Roads, Streets, and Highways reads much like a standard field guide, but it is hard to read it without imagining the author’s tongue placed firmly in cheek.[3]

 

Yet, the subject is deadly, pun intended, serious. 1.2 million wild ungulates —mostly deer but also elk and moose— were killed by vehicles in the United States in 2015.[4] While roadkill deaths are hard to quantify due to underreporting, especially if there was no property damage it is estimated that in 2014, 340 million birds fell victim to death by vehicle.[5]

 

As discussed, anthropogenically created edge is a symptom of habitat fragmentation. Another symptom of habitat fragmentation is barriers to dispersal. Barriers to dispersal need not be permanent, nor are they necessarily manmade. They can occur when an individual leaves its place of origin or breeding site, during transit, and in the process of settling into a new breeding site. Humans can also facilitate dispersal, though not always in an environmentally beneficial way, such as transporting seeds or insects on shipboard.[6] As a result contemporary ecological theory places a lot of emphasis on habitat connectivity and the creation of corridors. Barriers to dispersal are any barriers that prevent species from moving or expanding their territory. These are of concern on both the macro-level: individual or groups of members of a species, and the micro-level, such as the movement of a species’ genes.[7] The assumption of predictive modelling of responses to climate change is that most species will, in theory, move northward to cooler climates.[8]

 

The most obvious example of an anthropogenically created barrier to dispersal is a road. Hence, the attention paid here to roadkill. More roadkill occurs in spring and autumn, as these are the times of year that animals move from or to breeding sites, or in search of mates, and more roadkill occurs at dawn and dusk, as these are the times that animals are on the move, and human sight is limited.[9] There is, in fact serious science being done to evaluate the routes that various species traverse and then using that information to make those routes safer. Evidence suggests that animals will more readily adapt to changes in their route than humans will respond to signs and the like along theirs’.[10] One such researcher is wildlife ecologist and Assistant Professor at SUNY Plattsburgh Danielle Garneau .[11] Professor Garneau has created a mobile app called RoadkillGarneau via EpiCollect by which citizen science volunteers can submit photographs and data of their observations, allowing Professor Garneau access to a much greater body of data than she would have been able to gather on her own.

 

I have recently found myself in the street in front of the house, collecting photographic evidence as well. Directly in front of my property, the road crests after drivers either come up a hill from the west, or down and around a slight curve from the east. The species that most often falls victim at this slight blind spot is the gray squirrel. There is a lovely wooded patch across the street and I suspect they are travelling from there to the pond and back. I must confess that while driving, I am more interested than ever in the innocent victims of vehicular violence.

Feces: What Can We Learn From It?

A student of nature should have an interest in, familiarity with and even be excited by feces, scat, detritus, roadkill, carrion, rot, decay, and fungus. My particular obsession is with fungi, but I realize that an understanding of all the aforementioned topics is essential to a complete understanding of any ecological system. Because nature is a system that is primarily cyclical, it is important for the student of nature to have a full comprehension of those cycles.

 

There is an abundance of information that can be gleaned from “waste.” Ask any hunter, or any farmer, if they have spent any time examining feces. If they are accomplished at what they do, they will, to a person, answer “yes.” For example, a hunter might examine deer feces for remains of undigested foodstuffs. By determining what foods the deer eats they can refine their search area to the source of the food. Additionally, by checking the temperature, they are able to determine how recently the animal defecated, helping them to determine direction, time elapsed and ultimately, location. Several hunter acquaintances of mine believe that the deer’s gender can be determined by the pattern of distribution of the feces. Males they assert will leave a “pile” because they confidently stand their ground while defecating. Females on the other hand tend to distribute their feces in a wider pattern because they are too vigilant of their safety to be comfortable standing in one place.

 

Now, with an increase in Citizen Science projects and the available technology, we are seeing an increase in feces-based projects. A quick Google search of “‘citizen science’ and ‘feces’” yielded over 60,000 items involving human, livestock, and wildlife projects. A number of those are focused on dog feces. For example, an app called PooPower is being used to GPS-tag and track incidences of dog feces that is not being removed from city streets.[1] Another project that got a good deal of coverage involved 1.5 million citizen science volunteers who reviewed some 175,000 photographs of penguins, leading to the conclusion that penguins use their feces to melt snow and ice, thereby exposing rock suitable as a place to deposit their eggs.[2]

 

A project that caught my attention was one in Southern California in which citizen science volunteers, working with National Park Service biologists collected and inspected urban coyote feces, primarily to examine the coyotes’ diet.[3] The samples were collected, dried, place in pantyhose and then run through a washing machine prior to examination. Data suggests an omnivorous diet and that, in Southern California, at least, house pets did not make up a significant portion of the diet.[4]

 

Below are some photographs of feces. Perhaps you will be able to identify the source and contents of those samples that I have not!

Old bones.

Old bones.

Bullfrog, Rana catesbeiana,  ♀

Bullfrog, Rana catesbeiana, ♀

Eastern Chipmunk, deceased, roadkill

Eastern Chipmunk, deceased, roadkill

Eastern Cottontail, deceased, roadkill

Eastern Cottontail, deceased, roadkill

Coyote, deceased, roadkill.

Coyote, deceased, roadkill.

Feces, White-tailed Deer

Feces, White-tailed Deer

Feces, unidentified on stone wall.

Feces, unidentified on stone wall.

Feces, unknown origin, cherry pits

Feces, unknown origin, cherry pits

Unknown fecal mass

Unknown fecal mass

Dessicated frog

Dessicated frog

Frog's legs

Frog's legs

Gray Squirrel, deceased, roadkill

Gray Squirrel, deceased, roadkill

Gray Squirrel, deceased, roadkill.

Gray Squirrel, deceased, roadkill.

No Dumping

No Dumping

No Dumping

No Dumping

Northern Water Snake,Nerodia sipedon

Northern Water Snake,Nerodia sipedon

Raccoon, deceased, roadkill.

Raccoon, deceased, roadkill.

Red Fox, juvenile, deceased

Red Fox, juvenile, deceased

Footprints in the snow.

Footprints in the snow.

Raccoon, Procyon lotor, deceased

Raccoon, Procyon lotor, deceased

Raccoon, Procyon lotor, deceased

Raccoon, Procyon lotor, deceased

RS hawk with raccoon carcass

RS hawk with raccoon carcass

Striped Skunk, deceased.

Striped Skunk, deceased.

Virginia Opossum, deceased, roadkill.

Virginia Opossum, deceased, roadkill.

White-tail deer, deceased, roadkill.

White-tail deer, deceased, roadkill.

White-tailed deer. deceased.

White-tailed deer. deceased.

Notes

Roadkill

[1] A quick search in Amazon for “roadkill cookbook,” will reveal a series of Roadkill Cookbooks by Buck Peterson; regional cookbooks from Michigan, Iowa, Wisconsin, Minnesota, Arkansas, Illinois, Florida, South Dakota, and Missouri; there is even one by Victoria Beckham.

[2] Kirk Johnson, “Laurie the Moose Lady Puts ‘Heart and Soul’ Into Roadkill,” The New York Times, August 26, 2016, http://www.nytimes.com/2016/08/27/us/laurie-the-moose-lady-puts-heart-and-soul-into-roadkill.html.

[3] Roger M. Knutson, Flattened Fauna, Revised: A Field Guide to Common Animals of Roads, Streets, and Highways, Revised edition (Ten Speed Press, 2013).

[4] Johnson, “Laurie the Moose Lady.”

[5] Amanda Hardy and Renee Seidler, “Our Highways’ Toll on Wildlife,” The New York Times, October 23, 2014, http://www.nytimes.com/2014/10/24/opinion/our-highways-toll-on-wildlife.html.

[6] Paul Caplat et al., “Looking beyond the Mountain: Dispersal Barriers in a Changing World,” Frontiers in Ecology & the Environment 14, no. 5 (June 2016): 262.

[7] Timothy G. Howard and Matthew D. Schlesinger, “Wildlife Habitat Connectivity in the Changing Climate of New York’s Hudson Valley,” Annals of the New York Academy of Sciences 1298, no. 1 (September 30, 2013): 108.

[8] Howard and Schlesinger, “Wildlife Habitat Connectivity”: 107.

[9] Hardy and Seidler, “Our Highway’s Toll.”; Mike Adams, “Summer Travel Season,” Defenders of Wildlife Blog, August 18, 2016, http://www.defendersblog.org/2016/08/summer-travel-season/.

[10] Ibid.

[11] Gerianne Wright, “SUNY Plattsburgh Assistant Professor Danielle Garneau Uses Smart Phones to Document Road Kill Sightings,” accessed September 23, 2016, http://web.plattsburgh.edu/about/profiles/faculty/garneau.php.; Sarah Harris, “The Sight Of Roadkill Makes A Pretty, Data-Rich Picture,” NPR.org, December 1, 2012, http://www.npr.org/sections/alltechconsidered/2012/12/02/166320907/the-sight-of-road-kill-makes-a-pretty-data-rich-picture.

Feces

[1] Lisa Feldkamp, “Citizen Science Tuesday: PooPower!,” Cool Green Science, December 2, 2014, http://blog.nature.org/science/2014/12/02/citizen-science-poo-power-biogas-water-quality-dog-bacteria/.

[2] Louis Dore, “1.5 Million Volunteers Have Discovered Penguins Have to Poo in Order to Breed,” The Independent, April 26, 2015, http://www.independent.co.uk/news/science/15-million-volunteers-discover-penguins-need-to-use-the-faeces-in-order-to-breed-10205199.html.; Jason Goldman, “Camera Traps & Citizen Science Reveal the Ice-Melting Power of Penguin Poop,” Earth Touch News Network, May 16, 2015, http://www.earthtouchnews.com/conservation/conservation/camera-traps-citizen-science-reveal-the-ice-melting-power-of-penguin-poop.

[3] Southern California Public Radio, “Collect Coyote Poop for the Glory of Science,” Southern California Public Radio, 53:20 700, http://www.scpr.org/programs/offramp/2016/05/04/48570/volunteers-needed-to-collect-and-analyze-coyote-po/.; Kate Kuykendall, “New Study Offers Insights into Los Angeles’ Most Urban Coyotes - Santa Monica Mountains National Recreation Area (U.S. National Park Service),” accessed October 10, 2016, https://www.nps.gov/samo/learn/news/new-study-la-urban-coyotes.htm.

[4] Besame, “Daily Bucket: Volunteers Inspect Urban Coyote Poop for Science - It’s a SoCal Thing,” Daily Kos, accessed September 18, 2016, http://www.dailykos.com/story/2016/9/17/1571277/-Daily-Bucket-volunteers-inspect-urban-coyote-poop-for-science-it-s-a-SoCal-thing.

LAT 41 degrees 50' 26" N, LON 073 degrees 54' 46" W
bottom of page